Is fifty shades of grey twilight fanfiction


"Fifty Shades of Grey" by E. L. James, a best-selling BDSM-romance novel, has quite an intriguing origin story. It began as a fan-fic based on the "Twilight�series, causing huge debate among fans, critics, and literary scholars. This article delves into the transformative journey "Fifty Shades" took from being a "Twilight" fanfiction to becoming a highly successful standalone franchise.

Origins as a Fan-Fic

The original work by E.L James was indeed a piece of fan-fiction �titled "Master of the Universe" �grounded on Stephenie Meyer's "Twilight." Both stories share striking similarities in characters, plots, and the interplay of romanticism and danger. These parallels sparked off numerous discussions on whether "Fifty Shades" could be classified as original work or merely an extension of Meyer's world.

Is fifty shades of grey twilight fanfiction

However, a closer analysis reveals the intent of the author to subvert and re-imagine elements from "Twilight." The transformation of meek Bella into the assertive Anastasia, vulnerable Edward into domineering Christian "Adonis" Grey signifies an inventive blurring of character boundaries that is typical in fan-fiction narratives.

The Role of Fanfiction.Net

The story of "Fifty Shades'" origins cannot be told without mentioning Fanfiction.Net, an interactive literary platform where the first drafts of "Master of the Universe" were published. Here, the central characters were Edward and Bella, retaining the "Twilight" context. James commanded an impressive fanbase who played a critical role in the evolution of "Fifty Shades."

Fanfiction.Net receives commendation for nurturing aspiring authors by providing a platform where they can experiment with canonical texts, gather community feedback, and develop their voices. Its democratization of literature creation becomes especially evident in case studies like "Fifty Shades."

Transition to Original Work

Negotiating the leash of copyright laws, the creator embarked on "Filing Off the Serial Numbers," a process where she changed character names, eliminated explicit "Twilight" references, and made other modifications to the narrative to make it more original.

This method is controversial, often inviting criticisms about plagiarism and lack of originality. However, this process resulted in a book series that, despite its contentious past, has wholly diverged from the "Twilight" series, in tone, direction, and maturity levels.

Impact on Popular Culture

E. L. James's series has left an indelible impact on mainstream culture, mainstreaming issues and tropes previously reserved for niche readers. Their influence is apparent in the subsequent wave of erotica and BDSM-focused works that flooded markets.

"Fifty Shades" was a game-changer, not only in terms of its content but also its unusual journey from fanfiction to published work, changing common perceptions about fanfiction. It demonstrated that fanfiction could provide a springboard for commercial success and recognition.


Is "Fifty Shades of Grey" a Twilight fanfiction?

Yes, "Fifty Shades of Grey" originated as a Twilight fanfiction named "Master of the Universe," written by E.L. James under the pseudonym Snowqueen's Icedragon.

How did "Fifty Shades of Grey" become a separate entity from "Twilight" fanfiction?

E.L. James undertook the process of "Filing Off the Serial Numbers," where she changed character names and removed explicit "Twilight" references. Over time, the narrative itself evolved and became more independent from "Twilight."

What impact has "Fifty Shades of Grey" had on popular culture?

"Fifty Shades of Grey" has significantly impacted popular culture by mainstreaming BDSM and erotica. Additionally, its journey as a fanfiction-turned-published-work has opened the door for similar transitions within the fanfiction community.


[1] Curry, A., Byers,C.,& Johnson,C. (2015)Transforming Work: The Lifecycle of Twilight Fanfiction 'Master of the Universe. In: Click, M., Lee, H., Hollis, H. (eds) 'Bitten by Twilight

[2] E.L. James. 'Fifty Shades Trilogy.' Vintage Books, a division of Random House, 2012.

[3]James, E. L. (2018). 'Grey: Fifty Shades of Grey as Told by Christian.' Vintage Books.

[4]Tushnet, R. (2017). "I’m a lawyer, not an ethnographer, Jim": Textual reuse and the shifting boundaries of fair use. In 'Fan Fiction and Copyright' (pp. 35-52). Routledge

Explore your companion in WeMate