Ever wondered how things would have turned out had Harry Potter been placed in Slytherin instead of Gryffindor? Would he still be the Chosen One destined to defeat Lord Voldemort? Would he still have been friends with Hermione Granger and Ron Weasley? This twist to the plot can be a metamorphosis, changing the whole universe of the magical world we have come to love. Let's explore this alternate reality with an ambitious, cunning, and rule-defying Harry.

Choosing Slytherin

The first significant change would be in the Sorting Hat's scene when instead of the gruelling decision to put the eleven-year-old Harry in Gryffindor, the Hat decisively proclaims, "Slytherin!". Despite protests from Harry, the Sorting Hat, reinforcing its belief via an ancient prophecy, decides that Slytherin is where he truly belongs. This immediate divergence places the hero in the perceived antagonist's territory, setting the stage for an interesting narrative.

Apprehensive and isolated at first, Harry begins to embrace the nuances of being a Slytherin, using his natural charisma, ambition and cunning for the greater good. His destiny still remains the same, to defeat Lord Voldemort. Yet, his methods and allies to accomplish it take a dramatic turn in the epic tale.

Altered Friendships

If Harry had been in Slytherin, his friendships would be dramatically altered. Hence, instead of the inseparable trio that we're accustomed to, with Ron and Hermione, a new bubble grows with Draco Malfoy and perhaps Daphne Greengrass. Draco, who could have been a villain, is painted in a softer light, grappling with his loyalty and family's expectations. He and Daphne become Harry's closest confidantes, sharing cunning plans, secrets and dreams.

Despite being in a different House, Harry and Hermione, with their shared academic ambitions, remain friends, although their bond is not as strong. As for Ron, their relationship becomes more complex given Ron's resentment towards Slytherins.

Harry and Snape

Speaking of Slytherin, what about the resident potions master, Severus Snape? Is his animosity toward Harry fueled less by a grudge for James Potter and more for the nagging suspicion that Harry may pose a threat to his loyalties?

Despite Snape's initial antagonism, he begins to see similarities between Harry and Lily. There is a gradual groom from foe to an unlikely mentor, both protectively overseeing his progress and guiding him through the Slytherin terrain. This shift offers a profound dynamic to Harry and Snape's relationship.

Harry's Character Development

Interestingly, Slytherin's influence would have driven a significantly different character development for Harry. He becomes a more pragmatic, ambitious, and self-reliant individual. Though still compassionate, he is more likely to bend the rules to ensure the defeat of Voldemort.

Instead of representing bravery and daring, Harry in Slytherin would grow into a leader, utilizing his ambition for noble deeds. It would be a fascinating character growth of him testing the waters of his own morality in this 'means justify the end' attitude.

Conclusion

The realm of 'What if?' is inherently intriguing as it potently shuffles the narrative dimensions. 'What if Harry Potter were in Slytherin?' presents an alluring yet unsettling twist that diverges from familiar landscapes. Despite the house change, the heart of the story remains: Harry's journey to overcome dark forces while navigating the trials and tribulations of growing up. Regardless of the house he represents, Harry is destined to be the hero that the wizarding world needs and deserves.

FAQ's

Q: Would Harry still be a Parselmouth?
A: Yes, Harry would still be a Parselmouth because it's an inherent capacity due to Voldemort's soul attached to him and not related to his house.

Q: Would Harry belong to the Horcrux Club?
A: As a Slytherin, Harry might likely stumble upon the Horcrux mystery much earlier, with Snape and Draco's closeness opening him up to darker arts and ancient magic.

Q: Would Harry still be in love with Ginny?
A: This is subjective to the plot developments but his feeling is likely to remain.

References

Rowling, J.K. (1997). Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone. Bloomsbury Publishing.

Rowling, J.K. (1998). Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets. Bloomsbury Publishing.

Rowling, J.K. (2003). Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix. Bloomsbury Publishing.

Explore your companion in WeMate