Everyone knows the rambunctious, straw hat-wearing pirate named Monkey D. Luffy from the beloved and long-running manga and anime series, "One Piece". But what if our bold, fearless protagonist chose a different path? What if Luffy had become a marine instead of a pirate? This popular fan theory questions the foundations of Luffy's character and the course of the entire world of "One Piece". Let's discuss in detail from different aspects.

Setting

The first aspect to consider is how the world setting of "One Piece" would change if Luffy was a marine. Would the seas still be dominated by four pirate emperors, or would law and order have a stronger hold over the world? This could significantly affect the world balance and the influence of the World Government.

Furthermore, considering Luffy's natural tendency towards justice and protecting the weak, it could be assumed that he would be a marine advocating for changes in the rotten system. He might play a crucial role in eliminating corruption, leading to a reformed marine system. This setting stands a stark contrast to the actual storyline where marines are shown in a relatively negative light.

Alignment of Luffy's Personality

Even though Luffy becoming a marine might sound bizarre given his free and adventurous nature, looking more closely, we see there is a distinct alignment with Luffy's personality and marine ethos. Marines are depicted as protectors of justice and peace, traits that Luffy already embodies.

The main catch though would be his inherent disdain for authority and rules. It could be antithetical to the disciplined and hierarchical structure of the marine. But then, knowing Luffy, he might create his own brand of marine, much like Garp, and remain endlessly entertaining while serving justice.

Character Relationships

This theory would definitely alter Luffy's relationships with the other characters significantly, which brings us to the next aspect. We can expect an entirely different dynamic between Luffy and his crew. What would happen to his comrades if he went marine? Would they be his subordinates or would they take a different direction altogether?

Furthermore, his rivals would also inevitably change. Luffy has battled quite a few marines, so it would be interesting to see who stepping into their shoes as adversaries.

Moreover, Luffy’s relationship with his brother Ace would become tense and conflicted, considering Ace was a pirate. It would likely lead to a stronger emphasis on their bond as they try to navigate through their opposing paths.

Luffy's Growth and Development

In the original story, Luffy's pirate adventures lead him to grow and mature as a character. Becoming a marine would wholly affect his growth and development. Are they going to be stagnant or can we see a Luffy who has a much better understanding and control of his powers?

Besides that, Luffy's moral compass might need to be recalibrated. As a pirate, he often bends rules and norms in order to uphold justice. But as a marine, with a defined set of laws and protocols, how would Luffy's morality evolve?

Conclusion

This fan theory certainly presents compelling and nuanced element to the storyline and the characters. It provides an opportunity to explore different dimensions and angles to 'what could have been'. Regardless of speculation, one thing is for sure, Luffy, with his unfaltering spirit and determination, will leave a mark wherever he goes, pirate or marine.

Common Questions

Q: Why would anyone think Luffy could be a marine? A: Considering Luffy's strong sense of justice and how he always stands up for the weak, it isn't a far stretch to imagine him as a marine.

Q: Would Luffy be able to tolerate the disciplined environment of the marine? A: While Luffy does have a problem with authority, he has consistently shown the ability to adapt to different situations.

Q: Can the other members of the Straw Hat crew be imagined as marines too? A: Given their diverse personalities, some might fit the role better than others. It would be a treat to see how each character evolves in a marine setting.

Explore your companion in WeMate