Introduction

Creating a compelling character in fanfiction can be as challenging as it is rewarding. One commonly raised question is how far authors can push their protagonists into the darker corners of human behavior before they become too abusive. As always in writing, this question doesn't have a clear-cut answer. So, in an attempt to make the evaluation, we'll examine it from several angles.

Character Traits

The first aspect to consider is the character traits. If you have relentlessly imbued your character with abusive tendencies, it may sever the reader's emotional connection and even induce discomfort. On the other hand, having a deeply flawed character can create an interesting dynamic, challenging readers to look beyond surface.

But the key here is balance. An aggressive character can be fascinating, but crossing the line into relentless abuse can turn a dynamically flawed character into a heartless monster, thus ruining the reader's voyage of discovery.

Context

The context in which the abuse happens is important. If the abuse is gratuitous and meaningless, and serves no purpose within the narrative, then yes, you have probably gone too far. However, if your story deals with heavy themes and the character's behavior is part of those themes, then it may be more acceptable to readers.

A story tackling themes of oppression, war, or survival in harsh environments may naturally involve characters displaying certain brutal tendencies. But the abuse must be integral to the storytelling and not just a splash of sensationalism.

Character Development

Similarly, character development is crucial. If your character starts off as abusive, do they remain so throughout the story? If there's no growth or change in your character's abusive tendencies, then it can seem repetitive and uninteresting at best or disturbing and offensive at worst.

However, if the character starts as abusive and changes over time, shedding their cruel layers and showing a capacity for compassion, that might constitute a powerful character arc, rendering tolerable what might otherwise seem abusive.

The Role of Fandom

Fanfiction stems from a community of passionate fans, and one should consider the potential reactions within this fandom. A story about beloved characters turning abusive can stir controversy, lead to negative feedback, or even cross fandom-established boundaries. It's crucial to ensure that the abusive behavior you portray will not jeopardize the fandom's ethos.

Some fandoms have strict rules for portraying characters, and violating them can earn backlash. Mature content warnings or trigger warnings can help readers understand what the story contains, but they only play a protective role. They cannot justly excuse the abuse within the story.

Reader Reaction

Arguably the most important perspective is that of the readership. If the majority of your readers think that your character is too abusive, it is highly probable they are. The overall reception can give you important insights into whether your approach is working.

To gauge reader reactions, authors can use websites like Archive of Our Own or FanFiction.Net where users can leave comments on the stories. A careful examination of these comments can provide valuable perspective on how your character and their actions are being received.

FAQs

Q1: Can I justify the abusive behavior of my character if they themselves are a victim? A: It's a delicate line to walk. You can show a character's abusive behavior as an outcome of their own trauma but it's important to not inadvertently glorify or excuse such behavior by doing so.

Q2: What recourse do I have if my writing is met with backlash? A: Constructive criticism should always be welcomed and any negative responses should be handled with grace. Apologies, clarifications, or edits may help. It may also be advisable in some situations to remove the story if it offends or hurts a significant part of your readership.

Q3: How should I respond if a reader considers my writing triggering? A: Adding content warnings at the beginning of your story can help prevent these situations. But if a reader is triggered, it's important to acknowledge their feelings, apologize sincerely, and possibly revise your work to limit potential harm.

References:

1. Jenkins, H. (2006). Fans, bloggers, and gamers: Exploring participatory culture. NYU press.

2. Tosenberger, C. (2008). Homosexuality at the online Hogwarts: Harry Potter slash fanfiction. Children's Literature, 36(1), 185-207.

3. Winnicott, D. (1963). The development of the capacity for concern. The Maturational Processes and the Facilitating Environment: Studies in the Theory of Emotional Development, 73-82.

Explore your companion in WeMate